How to Audit a Failing Google Ads Campaign

How to Audit a Failing Google Ads Campaign

The Challenge of Underperforming Google Ads

If your Google Ads aren’t delivering results, you’re not alone. In fact, campaigns can underperform due to bidding missteps, unclear targeting, or landing pages that don’t convert. To address this critical issue, fortunately, this guide shows how to audit a failing Google Ads campaign with a repeatable process. In essence, specifically, you’ll learn where to look, what to fix first, and how to measure impact—so you can improve ad performance, control ad spend, and ultimately drive better ROI.

Your Roadmap to Campaign Improvement

Underperforming campaigns cost time and money. As a result, the key is a focused audit that identifies the highest-impact fixes first. To provide you with a clear path forward, in this post, you’ll find a practical, seven-step auditing process covering structure, keywords, ads, landing pages, and tracking. By following this structured approach, by the end, you’ll have a prioritized action plan to boost conversion rate, lower cost per acquisition, and make your paid search efforts more effective.

Define Goals and Success Metrics (Step 1)

  • Clarify what “success” looks like: higher conversion rate, lower cost per conversion (CPA), or increased return on ad spend (ROAS).
  • Pick an evaluation window (14–30 days) and compare against the prior period.
  • Track metrics that tie back to business outcomes:
  • Conversion tracking (e.g., form fills, purchases) and conversion rate
  • Cost per conversion and ROAS
  • Click-through rate (CTR) and quality score
  • Ad performance by ad group and keyword

Audit Account Structure and Setup (Step 2)

  • Campaign hierarchy: organized by goal, product line, or target audiences? Avoid duplication.
  • Ad groups: ensure each group is tightly themed around a small set of related keywords.
  • Bidding strategy: automated bidding (target CPA/ROAS, maximize conversions) often outperforms manual CPC if set up correctly.
  • Conversion tracking: verify events are firing properly and the attribution model aligns with your measurement goals.
  • Ad extensions: use sitelinks, callouts, structured snippets, and call extensions to boost CTR and ad relevance.
review your search terms

Review Keywords and Search Terms (Step 3)

  • Match types: balance broad match keywords with phrase and exact match to control spend.
  • Search terms report: identify irrelevant queries eating your budget and add them to your negative keywords list.
  • Keyword gaps: use tools or Google’s recommendations to discover high-intent search terms you’re missing.
  • Negative keywords list: keep it updated to eliminate wasted ad spend.
  • Intent alignment: make sure each keyword’s intent matches the landing page offer for better Quality Score and conversions.

Evaluate Ad Copy and Creative (Step 4)

  • Relevance: headlines and descriptions should reflect the user’s search intent and include the primary keyword where natural.
  • Call to action: use clear CTAs like “Start your free trial,” “Get a free audit,” or “Book a demo today.”
  • Ad rotation: set up A/B tests for headlines, descriptions, and extensions. Pause underperformers and allocate budget to winners.
  • Quality Score signals: ensure ad copy, keywords, and landing page content are consistent to boost expected CTR.
  • Ad performance: review analytics for each ad group and refine messaging based on top-performing search terms.

Analyze Landing Pages and User Experience (Step 5)

  • Relevance: landing pages must match the ad’s promise. If you claim “free audit,” the page needs that form or offer front and center.
  • Page load speed: use Google’s PageSpeed Insights to confirm fast loading on desktop and mobile.
  • Clear conversion path: easy-to-use forms, prominent buttons, and concise benefit statements increase conversion rate.
  • On-page signals: headlines, bullet points, and images should echo ad copy for a seamless experience.
  • Mobile-friendly design: ensure responsive layout, legible text, and tappable buttons.
Tracking Attribution Data Quality

Verify Tracking, Attribution, and Data Quality (Step 6)

  • Conversion events: confirm every key action (purchase, sign-up, phone call) is tracked.
  • Data integrity: eliminate duplicate conversions and ensure timestamps align with click data.
  • Attribution model: choose last click, first click, linear, or data-driven based on your sales cycle.
  • Cross-channel consistency: if you run paid social or display, maintain uniform naming conventions and UTM parameters.

Prioritize Fixes and Implement Quick Wins (Step 7)

Priority ActionDetails
Adding high-intent keywordsIdentify and add high-performing keywords while removing low-intent terms to improve targeting.
Expand the negative keywords listBlock irrelevant search terms to reduce wasted ad spend and improve campaign efficiency.
Tighten ad groupsGroup ads more precisely to improve relevance and boost Quality Score.
Pause underperforming adsShift budget from poor performers to top-performing ads for better ROI.
Enhance landing pagesStrengthen calls to action and clarify value propositions to improve conversions.
Create a 2-week action planInclude daily tasks, clear ownership, and milestones for accountability.
Build real-time metrics dashboardTrack core metrics like conversions, CPA, ROAS, and CTR for instant performance insights.

Audit Checklist

  • Define success and select KPIs
  • Review campaign and ad-group structure
  • Inspect keywords, match types, and negative keywords list
  • Evaluate ad copy, messaging, and CTAs
  • Assess landing page relevance, speed, and UX
  • Confirm conversion tracking, attribution, and reporting
  • Implement prioritized fixes, test, and monitor results
Audit Checklist visual selection

Frequently Asked Questions

Begin by setting clear business goals and KPIs (target CPA, target ROAS, or qualified leads). First, confirm conversion tracking fires for every key action. Next, scan your Google Ads account for structure issues: campaigns should map to objectives, and each ad group should be tightly themed.

Then, review your keywords and match types. Be sure to open the search terms report daily and review your search terms to add negatives and cut irrelevant traffic. Also, improve ads by aligning headlines to intent and strengthening the call to action; use extensions to lift CTR. After that, check landing pages for message match, speed, and a simple path to convert.

Finally, choose a bidding strategy that fits your data volume (Target CPA/ROAS with solid tracking, or start with Max Conversions). Overall, this structured approach helps you audit your Google Ads, fix poor performance, and move toward successful Google Ads results.

Start with outcomes, not clicks. Specifically, track conversions, conversion rate, CPA, ROAS, and revenue. After that, compare periods to spot trends, and segment performance by device, location, audience, and keyword to see where efficiency rises or drops. Furthermore, review your search terms for relevance and build a negative keywords list to protect your budget.

Next, check the Quality Score components, like expected CTR, ad relevance, and landing page experience. Additionally, make sure your attribution model accurately reflects the buying journey. Once data quality is sound and wasted ad spend shrinks while conversions grow, your Google Ads account is on the path to successful Google Ads performance.

Ultimately, continuous monitoring and adjustment are key to maintaining and improving campaign success.

It depends on your market’s CPCs and your conversion rate. For example, at a $2 CPC, $20/day buys about 10 clicks; with that, and a 5% conversion rate, that’s roughly one conversion every two days—which is enough to learn slowly. However, in competitive niches with $8–$15 CPCs, $20/day yields too few clicks to judge performance.

If $20 is your ceiling, then narrow targeting (locations, exact/phrase match, ad schedule), focus on one tightly themed ad group, and keep landing pages laser‑relevant. As you audit your Google Ads, raise budget once you see stable CPA or ROAS. Ultimately, the goal isn’t a magic number—it’s enough volume to make confident decisions without fueling poor performance.

Treat testing like the scientific method. Essentially, first, form a single hypothesis (for instance, “Benefit‑led headline will improve CTR”). Then, to ensure scientific validity, create a controlled A/B test—use Google Ads Experiments or duplicate ad groups—and split traffic 50/50. Critically, keep budgets steady and change only one variable at a time: ad copy, bidding strategy, audience, or landing page.

To gather sufficient data, run the test long enough to collect meaningful results, typically a few hundred clicks per variant. Meanwhile, review your search terms to maintain traffic quality throughout the test. Once a clear winner emerges, ship it across the account, document the learning, and queue the next test. In essence, continuous, disciplined testing is how you turn small insights into successful google ads.

🚀 Need help with your digital marketing? Contact AdExpert today to grow your business in Los Angeles!

Final Takeaways: How to Audit a Failing Google Ads Campaign and Win

A systematic audit is the fastest path to turning around a failing Google Ads campaign. By diligently focusing on key areas like defining goals, tightening account structure, refining keywords and ads, improving landing pages, and ensuring accurate tracking, you can significantly reduce waste and thereby boost ad performance.

Ultimately, this strategic process empowers you to unlock better results. Ready to implement these steps and see real improvements? Dive in today—your next set of conversions is just an audit away!

Author

  • Sam Ashrafi

    Sam Ashrafi is a highly experienced marketing strategist and co-founder in Los Angeles, California. With over a decade of experience in local and e-commerce marketing, Sam has a strong track record of developing and implementing successful marketing strategies for various businesses.

    Sam is enthusiastic about the potential of AI and digital marketing to revolutionize the industry, and he has a deep understanding of the latest trends and techniques in these areas. He is an expert in Google Ads, SEO, and content marketing, and he has helped numerous businesses to improve their online presence and drive more traffic to their websites.

    View all posts
Call Now Button